Nov 11, · Kitsch loots real art, borrows what it needs, converts inventions into formulas, waters down experiments and turns out familiar art-like images mechanically. Often overlooked in the numerous analyses of this essay is Greenberg’s lengthy and perceptive discussion of the relationship between kitsch and the regimes in Germany, Italy and Russia Clement Greenberg Kitsch Essay Using our cheap essay writing help is beneficial not only because of Clement Greenberg Kitsch Essay its easy access and low /10() Greenberg Kitsch Essay assignments are thoroughly checked by Greenberg Kitsch Essay our editors on grammar, punctuation, structure, transitions, references, and formatting errors. We carefully read and correct essays so that you will receive a paper that is ready for submission or publication/10()
“The Avant-Garde and Kitsch,” by Clement Greenberg | Art History Unstuffed
Clement Greenberg. This is Greenberg's breakthrough essay fromwritten for greenberg kitsch essay Partisan Review when he was twenty-nine years of age and at the time more involved with literature than with painting.
He came, later, to reject much of the essay -- notably the definition of kitsch which he later believed to be ill thought out as, indeed, it is, greenberg kitsch essay. Later he came to identify the threat to high art as coming from middlebrow taste, which in any event aligns much more closely with the academic than kitsch ever did or could.
The essay has an air and assurance of '30s Marxism, with peculiar assumptions such as that only under socialism could the taste of the masses be raised. But for all that, the essay stakes out new territory.
Although the avant-garde was an accepted fact in the '30s. Greenberg was the first to greenberg kitsch essay its social and historical context and cultural import.
The essay also carried within it the seeds of his notion of modernism. Despite its faults and sometimes heady prose, it stands as one greenberg kitsch essay the important theoretical documents of 20th century culture. O NE AND THE SAME civilization produces simultaneously two such different things s a poem by T, greenberg kitsch essay. Eliot and a Tin Pan Alley song, or a painting by Braque and a Saturday Evening Post cover.
All four are on the order of culture, and ostensibly, parts of the same culture and products of the same society. Here, however, their connection seems to end. A poem by Eliot and a poem by Eddie Guest -- what perspective of culture is large enough to enable us to situate them in an enlightening relation to each other? Does the fact that a disparity such as this within the frame of a single cultural tradition, which is and has been taken for granted -- does this fact indicate that the disparity is a part of the natural order of things?
Or is it something entirely new, and particular to our age? The answer involves more than an investigation greenberg kitsch essay aesthetics.
It appears to me that it is necessary to examine more closely and with more originality than hitherto the relationship between aesthetic experience as met by the specific -- not the generalized -- individual, and the social and historical contexts in which that experience takes place.
What is brought to light will answer, in addition to the question posed above, other and perhaps more important questions. A society, greenberg kitsch essay it becomes less and less able, in the course of its development, to justify the inevitability of its particular forms, breaks up the accepted notions upon which artists and writers must depend in large part for communication with their audiences.
It becomes difficult to assume anything. All the verities involved by religion, authority, tradition, style, are thrown into question, and the writer or artist is no longer able to estimate the response of his audience to the symbols and references with which he works.
In the past such a state of affairs has usually resolved itself into a motionless Alexandrianism, an academicism in which the really important issues are left untouched because they involve controversy, and in which creative activity dwindles to virtuosity in the small details of form, all larger questions being decided by the precedent of the old masters.
The same themes are mechanically varied in a hundred different works, and yet nothing new is produced: Statius, mandarin verse, Roman sculpture, Beaux-Arts painting, neo-republican architecture. It is among the hopeful signs in the midst of the decay of our present society that we -- some of us -- have been unwilling to accept this last phase for our own culture.
In seeking to go beyond Alexandrianism, a part greenberg kitsch essay Western bourgeois society has produced something unheard of heretofore: -- avant-garde culture. A superior consciousness of history -- more precisely, the appearance of a new kind of criticism of society, an historical criticism greenberg kitsch essay made this possible. This criticism has not confronted our present society with timeless utopias, but has soberly examined in the terms of history and of cause and effect the antecedents, justifications and functions of the forms that lie at the heart of every society.
Thus our present bourgeois social order was shown to be, greenberg kitsch essay, not an eternal, greenberg kitsch essay, "natural" condition of life, but simply the latest term in a succession of social orders, greenberg kitsch essay.
New perspectives of this kind, becoming a part of the advanced intellectual conscience of the fifth and sixth decades of the nineteenth century, soon were absorbed by artists and poets, even if unconsciously for the most part. It was no accident, therefore, that the birth of the avant-garde coincided chronologically -- and geographically, too -- with the first bold development of scientific revolutionary thought in Europe. True, greenberg kitsch essay, the first settlers of bohemia -- which was then identical with the avant-garde -- turned out soon to be demonstratively uninterested in politics.
Nevertheless, without the circulation of revolutionary ideas in the air about them, greenberg kitsch essay would never have been able to isolate their concept of the "bourgeois" in order to define what they were not. Nor, without the moral aid of revolutionary political attitudes would they have had the courage to assert themselves as aggressively as they did against the prevailing standards of society. Courage indeed was needed for this, because the avant-garde's emigration from bourgeois society to bohemia meant also an emigration from the greenberg kitsch essay of capitalism, upon which artists and writers had been thrown by the falling away of greenberg kitsch essay patronage.
Ostensibly, greenberg kitsch essay, at least, it meant this -- meant starving in a garret -- although, as we will be shown later, the avant-garde remained attached to bourgeois society precisely because it needed its money. Yet it is true that once the avant-garde greenberg kitsch essay succeeded in "detaching" itself from society, it proceeded to turn around and repudiate revolutionary as well as bourgeois politics.
The revolution was left inside society, greenberg kitsch essay, a part of that welter of ideological struggle which art and poetry find so unpropitious as soon as it begins to involve those "precious" axiomatic beliefs upon which culture thus far has had to rest.
Hence it developed that the true and most important function of the greenberg kitsch essay was not to "experiment," but to find a path along which it would be possible to keep culture moving in the midst of ideological confusion and violence.
Retiring from public altogether, the avant-garde poet or artist sought to maintain the high level of his art by both narrowing and raising it to the expression of an absolute in which all relativities and contradictions would be either resolved or beside the point. It has been in search of the absolute that the avant-garde has greenberg kitsch essay at "abstract" or "nonobjective" art greenberg kitsch essay and poetry, too, greenberg kitsch essay.
The avant-garde greenberg kitsch essay or artist tries in effect to imitate God by creating something valid solely on its own terms, in the way nature itself is valid, in the way a greenberg kitsch essay -- not its picture -- is aesthetically valid; something given, increate, independent of meanings, similars or originals. Content is to be dissolved so completely into form that the work of art greenberg kitsch essay literature cannot be reduced in whole or in part to anything not itself.
But the absolute is absolute, and the poet or artist, being what he is, cherishes certain relative values more than others.
The very values in the name of which he invokes the absolute are relative values, the values of aesthetics. And so he turns out to be imitating, not God -- and here I use "imitate" in its Aristotelian sense -- but the disciplines and processes of art and literature themselves. This is the genesis of the "abstract. The nonrepresentational or "abstract," if it is to have aesthetic validity, cannot be arbitrary and accidental, but must stem from obedience to some worthy constraint or original.
This constraint, once the world of common, extroverted experience has been renounced, can only be found in the very processes or disciplines by which art and literature have already imitated the former. These themselves become the subject matter of art and literature. If, to continue with Aristotle, all art and literature are imitation, then what we have here is the imitation of imitating. To quote Yeats:.
Picasso, Braque, Mondrian, greenberg kitsch essay, Miro, Kandinsky, Brancusi, even Klee, Matisse and Cézanne derive their chief inspiration from the medium they work in. The attention greenberg kitsch essay poets like Rimbaud, Mallarmé, Valéry, Éluard, Pound, Hart Crane, Stevens, even Rilke and Yeats, appears to be centered on the effort to create poetry and on the "moments" themselves of poetic conversion, rather than on experience to be converted into poetry.
Of course, this cannot exclude other preoccupations in their work, for poetry must deal with words, greenberg kitsch essay, and words must communicate. Certain poets, such as Mallarmé and Valéry 3 are more radical in this respect than others -- leaving aside those poets who have tried to compose poetry in pure sound alone.
However, if it were easier to define poetry, modern poetry would be greenberg kitsch essay more "pure" and "abstract. But aside from the fact that most of our best contemporary novelists have gone to school with the avant-garde, it is significant that Gide's most ambitious book is a novel about the writing of a novel, and that Joyce's Ulysses and Finnegans Wake seem to be, above all, as one French critic says, the reduction of experience to expression for the sake of expression, the expression mattering more than what is being greenberg kitsch essay. That avant-garde culture is the imitation of imitating -- the fact itself -- calls for neither approval nor disapproval.
It is true that this culture contains greenberg kitsch essay itself some of the very Alexandrianism it seeks to overcome. The lines quoted from Yeats referred to Byzantium, greenberg kitsch essay, which is very close to Alexandria; and in a sense this imitation of imitating is a superior sort of Alexandrianism.
But there is one most important difference: the avant-garde moves, greenberg kitsch essay, while Alexandrianism stands still. And this, precisely, is what justifies the avant-garde's methods and makes them necessary. The necessity lies in the fact that by no other means is it possible today to create art and literature of a high order. To quarrel with necessity by throwing about terms like "formalism," "purism," "ivory tower" and so forth is either dull or dishonest.
This is not to say, however, that it is to the social greenberg kitsch essay of the avant-garde that it is what it is. Quite the opposite. The avant-garde's specialization of itself, the fact that its best artists are artists' artists, its best poets, poets' poets, has estranged a great many of those who were capable formerly of enjoying and appreciating ambitious art and literature, but who are now unwilling or unable to acquire an initiation into their craft secrets.
The masses have always remained more or less indifferent to culture in the process of development. But today such culture is being abandoned by those to whom it actually belongs -- our ruling class. For it is to the latter that the avant-garde belongs. No culture can develop without a social basis, without a source of stable income. And in the case of the avant-garde, this was provided by an elite among the ruling class of that society from which it assumed itself to be cut off, but to which it has always remained attached by an umbilical cord of gold, greenberg kitsch essay.
The paradox is real. And now this elite is rapidly shrinking. Since the avant-garde forms the only living culture we now have, the survival in the near future of culture in general is thus threatened.
We must not be deceived by superficial phenomena and local successes. Picasso's shows still draw crowds, and T. Eliot is taught in the universities; the dealers in modernist art are still in business, and the publishers still publish some "difficult" poetry. But the avant-garde itself, already sensing the danger, is becoming more and more timid every day that passes. Academicism and commercialism are appearing in the strangest places. This can mean only one thing: that the avant-garde is becoming unsure of the audience it depends on -- the rich and the cultivated.
Is it the nature itself of avant-garde culture that is alone responsible for the danger it finds itself in? Or is that only a dangerous liability?
Are there other, and perhaps more important, factors involved? Where there is an avant-garde, greenberg kitsch essay, generally we also find a rear-guard. True enough -- simultaneously with the entrance of the avant-garde, a second new cultural phenomenon appeared in the industrial West: that thing to which the Germans give the wonderful name of Kitsch greenberg kitsch essay popular, commercial art and literature with their chromeotypes, magazine covers, illustrations, ads, slick and pulp fiction, comics, Tin Pan Alley music, tap dancing, greenberg kitsch essay, Hollywood movies, etc.
For some reason this gigantic apparition has always been taken for granted. It is time we looked into its whys and wherefores. Kitsch is a product of the industrial revolution which urbanized the masses of Western Europe and America and established what is called universal literacy. Prior to this the only market for formal culture, as distinguished from folk culture, had been among those who, in addition to being able to read and write, could command the leisure and comfort that always goes hand in hand with cultivation of some sort.
This until then had been inextricably associated greenberg kitsch essay literacy. But with the introduction of universal literacy, the ability to read and write became almost a minor skill like driving a car, and it no longer served to distinguish greenberg kitsch essay individual's cultural inclinations, since it was no longer the exclusive concomitant of refined tastes. The peasants who settled in the cities as proletariat and petty bourgeois learned to read and write for the sake of efficiency, but they did not win the leisure and comfort necessary for the enjoyment of the city's traditional culture.
Losing, nevertheless, their taste for the folk culture whose background was the countryside, and discovering a new capacity for boredom at the same time, the new urban masses set up a pressure on society to provide them with a kind of culture fit for their own consumption, greenberg kitsch essay.
To fill the demand of the new market, a new commodity was devised: ersatz culture, kitsch, greenberg kitsch essay, destined for those who, insensible to the values of genuine culture, are hungry nevertheless for the diversion that only culture of some sort can provide. Kitsch, using for raw material the debased and academicized simulacra of genuine culture, welcomes and cultivates this insensibility. It is the source of its profits, greenberg kitsch essay.
What is Kitsch?
, time: 11:40Greenberg: Avant-Gardde and Kitsch
Clement Greenberg Kitsch Essay Using our cheap essay writing help is beneficial not only because of Clement Greenberg Kitsch Essay its easy access and low /10() Sep 21, · Greenberg developed an essay known as the Avant-Garde and Kitsch which portrayed his views and those of other real artists on kitsch. The avante-garde movement arose to discredit this form of art which did not follow the aesthetic standards of achieving taste and truthfulness in art forms Apr 29, · In his essay ‘Avant-garde and Kitsch’, Clement Greenberg claims that avant-garde or modernist art is a tool to prevent the ordinary culture caused by consumerism. Also with in his essay Kitsch gained popularity
No comments:
Post a Comment